Open the app

Home / Guides / Pricing, breaks, and giveaways

Whatnot pricing, breaks, and giveaways

Fees, shipping you cover, and free spots all come out of the same show. This guide covers how to set a break-even price, how to cost a break or mystery box, and how to keep giveaways from quietly erasing a good night.

Price after fees, not before them

An 8% headline commission is not your all-in cost. In the US you also pay 2.9% + $0.30 on everything the buyer pays, including shipping and tax. On a Standard-tier $50 sale with $4.99 shipping and 7% tax, total fees are $6.00, or 12% of the item price. See the full breakdown in How much does Whatnot take?

Before you go live, run a typical item through the fee calculator and note the break-even sale price. That is the hammer or BIN price where you neither make nor lose money after fees, shipping you cover, and cost of goods. Auctions can still go lower, but you should know when they did.

Costing a break, case, or mystery box

The inventory in a break is bought as one lot and sold as many spots. If you assign no cost, every spot looks like free profit. If you dump the whole case cost onto the last hit, one order looks terrible and the rest look too good.

A cleaner method: enter one lot cost for the show and spread it across sales in proportion to price. A $200 spot on a $2,000 show carries 10% of the case; a $40 spot carries 2%. The show’s profit is then honest even if individual spots vary. ProfitPerShow does this when you type a lot cost or add a show-level row in a cost file.

If you sell high-end singles in the same week, remember that Whatnot’s 0% commission on the portion of an order above $1,500 applies to Sports Singles in listed subcategories, but sports breaks and surprise products are excluded from that promotion. Source: Reduced Commission on High-Value Orders, checked November 13, 2026.

What a giveaway really costs

Sellers pay shipping on physical Whatnot giveaways, including international shipping if it is enabled, and the charge comes out of your balance when the giveaway runs. Source: About giveaways on Whatnot.

Add the prize cost. Five $8 prizes at the $4.85 Ground Advantage rate (4 oz to under 8 oz, effective July 31, 2026) cost $64.25. If a typical $50 sale makes $24 after fees and cost, you need three of those sales just to break even on the giveaways. Use the giveaway and break-even calculator before you plan the night, and the show profit estimator to see the whole stream.

Giveaways can still be worth it when they clearly create extra paying buyers. The point is to measure them, not to treat “free” as free.

A pre-show checklist

Related guides and tools

Sources

FAQ

How do I set a break-even price on Whatnot after fees?

Start with what the item cost you, add any shipping you will cover, then raise the sale price until profit is zero after commission and payment processing. Processing is 2.9% plus $0.30 on the full amount the buyer pays, so tax and buyer shipping change the number slightly. A calculator is faster than doing this by hand.

How should I cost a sports card break?

Put the full cost of the box, case, or group break into the show as one lot cost, then spread it across the spots in proportion to what they sold for. That prevents a cheap spot from looking wildly profitable and an expensive hit from looking worse than it was. Sports breaks are also excluded from Whatnot’s high-value 0% commission promotion.

Are Whatnot giveaways worth it?

Only if the extra sales, tips, or return viewers they create cover the prize cost and the shipping you pay. Price the giveaway first, then decide how many paying spots you need. A giveaway that costs $12.85 is not “free marketing” until the show clears that amount in extra profit.

Does a lower starting bid help profit?

A $1 start can fill a room and still lose money if the hammer price never clears fees and cost. Use a break-even price as a floor for BIN listings and as a gut check after auctions. If a category regularly sells below that floor, the problem is sourcing cost or show format, not just the fee rate.